Positive diversity effects on productivity in mixtures of arable weed species as related to density-size relationships

doi:10.1093/jpe/rtw013

Abstract

Abstract: Aims Diversity–productivity relationships among herbaceous species have mostly been studied in grasslands, while less is known about diversity effects among weedy species with a short life cycle.
Methods We studied diversity–productivity relationships, shoot density, size and allometry in experimental communities of different species richness (one, three, six, and nine species), functional group number (one to three functional groups: grasses, small herbs and tall herbs) and functional group evenness (even and uneven number of species per functional group) based on a pool of nine arable weed species with a short life cycle in a 2-year experiment.
Important findings Higher species richness increased above- and belowground biomass production in both years of the experiment. Additive partitioning showed that positive selection effects increased with increasing species richness and functional group number, while positive complementarity effects were greater when tall herbs were present. Relative yield totals were larger than 1 across all species richness levels but did not increase with species richness, which is consistent with constant positive complementarity effects. Community biomass production and diversity effects increased in the second year of the experiment, when communities achieved greater shoot densities and average shoot sizes. At the community level, varying productivity was mainly attributable to variation in mean shoot sizes. Tall herbs reached greater observed/expected relative yields (=overyielding) due to increased shoot sizes, underyielding of small herbs was mainly attributable to decreased shoot sizes, while grasses partly compensated for reduced shoot sizes by increasing densities. Shifts in community-level density–size relationships and changes in shoot allometry in favour of greater height growth indicated that a greater biomass at a given density was due to increased dimensions of occupied canopy space. We conclude that diversity effects are also possible among short-lived arable weed species, but selection effects through sizes differences among species are key for positive species richness–productivity relationships.

Key words: allometry, biodiversity, complementarity effects, density, selection effects

摘要：
Aims Diversity–productivity relationships among herbaceous species have mostly been studied in grasslands, while less is known about diversity effects among weedy species with a short life cycle.
Methods We studied diversity–productivity relationships, shoot density, size and allometry in experimental communities of different species richness (one, three, six, and nine species), functional group number (one to three functional groups: grasses, small herbs and tall herbs) and functional group evenness (even and uneven number of species per functional group) based on a pool of nine arable weed species with a short life cycle in a 2-year experiment.
Important findings Higher species richness increased above- and belowground biomass production in both years of the experiment. Additive partitioning showed that positive selection effects increased with increasing species richness and functional group number, while positive complementarity effects were greater when tall herbs were present. Relative yield totals were larger than 1 across all species richness levels but did not increase with species richness, which is consistent with constant positive complementarity effects. Community biomass production and diversity effects increased in the second year of the experiment, when communities achieved greater shoot densities and average shoot sizes. At the community level, varying productivity was mainly attributable to variation in mean shoot sizes. Tall herbs reached greater observed/expected relative yields (=overyielding) due to increased shoot sizes, underyielding of small herbs was mainly attributable to decreased shoot sizes, while grasses partly compensated for reduced shoot sizes by increasing densities. Shifts in community-level density–size relationships and changes in shoot allometry in favour of greater height growth indicated that a greater biomass at a given density was due to increased dimensions of occupied canopy space. We conclude that diversity effects are also possible among short-lived arable weed species, but selection effects through sizes differences among species are key for positive species richness–productivity relationships.

Christiane Roscher, Jens Schumacher. Positive diversity effects on productivity in mixtures of arable weed species as related to density-size relationships[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2016, 9(6): 792-804.

[1]	Mingyang Liu, Weiren Wang, Qing Ye, Hui Liu, Ronghua Li, Shidan Zhu, Osazee O Oyanoghafo, Pengcheng He. Trade-offs between water use efficiency and hydraulic conductivity across 52 woody species distributed in three forests along a precipitation gradient [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[2]	Qichang Li , Zixuan Chen , Keqing Liu , Zhili Liu , Guangze Jin. Contrasting roles of overstorey and understorey structural diversity in regulating temperate forest productivity [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[3]	Yarong Sun, Jian Li, Guowei Liang, Yunming Chen. Planting density modulates soil organic carbon sources by regulating plant lignin and microbial necromass C in temperate forests [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[4]	Jingci Meng, Guodong Wang, Ming Wang, Meiling Zhao, Yusong Yuan, Nanlin Hu, Qi Chen, Tao Zhang, Bo Liu, Zhenshan Xue, and Ming Jiang. Abiotic and biotic factors jointly affect aboveground biomass in sedge wetlands of China [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[5]	Yun Liang, Mingyan Hu, Scott X. Chang, Stavros Veresoglou, Mengxue Wang, Anqi Dong, Jie Wang, Chenyan Huang, Yiling Tian, Zilong Ma, Chengjin Chu. Community leaf nutrient characteristics drive soil carbon stabilization by regulating soil nutrient and microbial community in a subtropical forest plantation [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[6]	Chao Jin, Jing Yang, Siyu Wu, Qiuwu Yu, Xihua Wang, Guochun Shen. Canopy height and stand density mask nature’s inherent synergy between forest structural complexity and diversity [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[7]	Boliang Wei, Jiejie Jiao, Fangdong Zheng, Guochun Shen, Theint Theint Soe, Miaoyan Liu, Jinwang Wang, Yunquan Wang, Lei Zhong, Jinliang Liu, Yuan Tian, Zupei Lei, Mingjian Yu. A fine-grained look at density dependence: the importance of heterospecific neighbors [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[8]	Chunyue Yao, Jinchao Feng, Yeming Zhang, Zhenhua Dang, Linna Ma. Plant diversity dominates the regulation of ecosystem multifunctionality under grazing management in temperate grasslands [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-40.
[9]	Yang Li, Jiangchao Guo, Yaoxin Guo, Yongfu Chai, Ming Yue. Shrubland carbon storage in northern China: a synergistic analysis of climate, plant community and soil traits [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-40.
[10]	Gianalberto Losapio, Lucía Mottet, Nora Khelidj, Bao Ngan Tu, Bruno E.L. Cerabolini, Stephanie Grand, Natasha de Vere, Antoine Guisan. Ecological indicators predict functional diversity dynamics following glacier retreat [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-37.
[11]	Ya Wang, Aiyan Han, Qiaoqiao Huang. Effects of nutrient and density on plant–soil feedbacks of co-occurring invasive and native plants [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-40.
[12]	Zhiwen Guo, Jun Tang, Guozhen Lai, Liting Liu, Xiangping Wang. Structural diversity primarily drives forest biomass along altitudinal gradients in subtropical forests [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-.
[13]	Junjiong Shao, Xuhui Zhou, Lingyan Zhou, Yan Li. Plant biomass-leaf area allometry and ambient plant traits predict biomass responses to global warming [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-15.
[14]	Pengcheng Jiang, Han He, Zikun Mao, Yanjun Su, Mengxu Zhang, Meihui Zhu, Zhichao Xu, Jin Yin, Hongyi Jiang, Shuai Fang, Xugao Wang. Canopy properties predominately explain above-ground biomass stock in temperate forests [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(2): 1-14.
[15]	Junxiang Ding, Mingli Zhang, Xiaowen Zeng, Ming Dou, Wenjing Ge, Yingshu Cao, Qingbin Mi, Jihua Wang, Fengmin Lu, Liang Zhao, Deliang Kong, Huajun Yin, Lin Wang, Guangsheng Zhou. Soil nutrients drive the spatial variability of wetland productivity along degradation gradients through plant functional traits [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(2): 1-15.