Differentiation between true mangroves and mangrove associates based on leaf traits and salt contents

doi:10.1093/jpe/rtq008

Abstract

Abstract: Aims Mangrove species are classified as true mangroves and mangrove associates. However, as for some fringe species found mainly on the landward transitional zones of mangroves, no consensus among scientists could be reached in favor of this classification and much debate arises. We hypothesized that true mangroves differ from mangrove associates physiologically and ecologically in their ability to survive in mangrove environment.
Methods To test this hypothesis, leaf structural traits and osmotic properties were used to describe variation in 33 mangrove species (17 true mangroves, 6 mangrove associates and 10 controversial species).
Important findings Specific leaf area (SLA) of true mangroves as well as leaf nitrogen concentration on a leaf mass (Nmass) were lower than that of mangrove associates; leaf succulence was, in general, twice as high in true mangroves compared to mangrove associates; true mangroves accumulated 8–9 times more Na and Cl than mangrove associates and the former had K/Na ratios <0.5, but the latter had K/Na ratios>0.5. These results indicated that true mangroves differed reliably from mangrove associates in leaf traits and osmotic properties. True mangroves are true halophytes and mangrove associates are glycophytes with certain salt tolerance. Combining distribution pattern information, the 10 controversial species were reclassified.

Key words: mangrove, leaf trait, chemical composition, osmotic adaptation, classification

摘要：
Aims Mangrove species are classified as true mangroves and mangrove associates. However, as for some fringe species found mainly on the landward transitional zones of mangroves, no consensus among scientists could be reached in favor of this classification and much debate arises. We hypothesized that true mangroves differ from mangrove associates physiologically and ecologically in their ability to survive in mangrove environment.
Methods To test this hypothesis, leaf structural traits and osmotic properties were used to describe variation in 33 mangrove species (17 true mangroves, 6 mangrove associates and 10 controversial species).
Important findings Specific leaf area (SLA) of true mangroves as well as leaf nitrogen concentration on a leaf mass (Nmass) were lower than that of mangrove associates; leaf succulence was, in general, twice as high in true mangroves compared to mangrove associates; true mangroves accumulated 8–9 times more Na and Cl than mangrove associates and the former had K/Na ratios <0.5, but the latter had K/Na ratios>0.5. These results indicated that true mangroves differed reliably from mangrove associates in leaf traits and osmotic properties. True mangroves are true halophytes and mangrove associates are glycophytes with certain salt tolerance. Combining distribution pattern information, the 10 controversial species were reclassified.

Liangmu Wang, Meirong Mu, Xiaofei Li, Peng Lin, Wenqing Wang. Differentiation between true mangroves and mangrove associates based on leaf traits and salt contents[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2011, 4(4): 292-301.

[1]	Guoming Qin, Zhe Lu, Shuchai Gan, Lulu Zhang, Jingfan Zhang, Jinge Zhou, Ruyi Ding, Xingyun Huang, Hua He, Senhao Wang, Hui Li, Jingtao Wu, Faming Wang. Spartina alterniflora invasion stimulates methane emissions in coastal wetlands by increasing labile organic matter and shifting microbial communities [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[2]	Yanju Gao, Akash Tariq, Fanjiang Zeng, Jordi Sardans, Dhafer A Al-Bakre, Josep Peñuelas. Seasonal dynamics and allocation patterns of foliar phosphorus fractions in deep-rooted desert species under phosphorus-poor environments [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[3]	Yuyao Nan, Chuanshan Zou, Xingchang Wang, Qi Wang. Leaf non-structural carbohydrates dominantly drive background insect herbivory of temperate tree species in Northeast China [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[4]	Boliang Wei, Jiejie Jiao, Fangdong Zheng, Guochun Shen, Theint Theint Soe, Miaoyan Liu, Jinwang Wang, Yunquan Wang, Lei Zhong, Jinliang Liu, Yuan Tian, Zupei Lei, Mingjian Yu. A fine-grained look at density dependence: the importance of heterospecific neighbors [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[5]	Ting-Ting Liu, Dan-Dan Zhang, Meng-Ying He, Jin-Sheng Li, Hong-Miao Wu, Wen-Yu Jiang, Yi-Yi Long, Xu-Rui Zhu, Zhen Zhang. Effects of different intensities of artificial light at night on functional traits of invasive and native plants [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-14.
[6]	Huifang Wu, Qingpei Yang, Jing Chen, Mingzhen Lu, Weizheng Ren, Yanmei Xiong, Yuxin Pei, Preetika B. Chand, Oscar J. Valverde-Barrantes, Jingjing Cao, Deliang Kong. Divergent leaf–root coordination between mangroves and non-mangroves [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(2): 1-14.
[7]	Yangping Guo, Xincong Chen, Fujia Wu, Wenwen Liu, Yihui Zhang. Latitudinal variation in leaf functional traits of an invasive salt-marsh plant and its relationship with growth performance [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(1): 1-19.
[8]	Jing Zhu, Xue-Lin Wang, Xing Jin, Lan Jiang, Hong-Yu Lin, Yang Hu, Jin-Fu Liu, Zhong-Sheng He. Relative position of seeds driven the seedling growth are mediated by root-leaf traits [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2024, 17(2): 0-rtae004.
[9]	Wenqi Luo, Oscar J Valverde-Barrantes, Monique Weemstra, James F Cahill Jr, Zi Wang, Dong He, Yongfa Chen, Chengjin Chu, Youshi Wang. Leaf and root traits are partially coordinated but they show contrasting multi-trait-based community trait dispersion patterns in a subtropical forest [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2024, 17(1): 1-.
[10]	Yizhen Liu, Haihua Shen, Gang Ge, Aijun Xing, Zhiyao Tang and Jingyun Fang. Classification and distribution of evergreen broad-leaved forests in Jiangxi, East China [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2023, 16(1): 0-.
[11]	Audrey F. Haynes. What do we know about parasitic plants and the leaf economic spectrum? [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2022, 15(4): 691-699.
[12]	Sridevi Ravi, Martin K.-F. Bader, Tim Young, Mark Duxbury, Michael Clearwater, Cate Macinnis-Ng and Sebastian Leuzinger. Are the well-fed less thirsty? Effects of drought and salinity on New Zealand mangroves [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2022, 15(1): 85-99.
[13]	Yutong Lin, Luhui Kuang, Songbo Tang, Zhijian Mou, Oliver L. Phillips, Hans Lambers, Zhanfeng Liu, Jordi Sardans, Josep Peñuelas, Yuan Lai, Mingxian Lin, Dexiang Chen, and Yuanwen Kuang. Leaf traits from stomata to morphology are associated with climatic and edaphic variables for dominant tropical forest evergreen oaks [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(6): 1115-1127.
[14]	Yaoqi Li, Dongting Zou, Nawal Shrestha, Xiaoting Xu, Qinggang Wang, Wen Jia and Zhiheng Wang. Spatiotemporal variation in leaf size and shape in response to climate [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(1): 87-96.
[15]	Changcheng Liu, Thomas R. Wentworth, Xianguo Qiao, Ke Guo and Dongjie Hou. Vegetation classification at the association level under the China Vegetation Classification System: an example of six Stipa steppe formations in China [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(6): 1009-1024.