Trees are rarely most abundant where they grow best

doi:10.1093/jpe/rtr036

Abstract

Abstract: Aims A common assumption in ecology is that where a species is found to be most abundant must correspond to the environmental context in which the species performs the best (i.e. optimal niche space). This assumption is central to common conservation and management tools such as habitat suitability assessment and species distribution modeling. I test this hypothesis.
Methods I use the US Forest Inventory Assessment data for the abundance of trees across eastern North America. I use the FORAST tree-ring dataset for ontogenetic growth rate (tree-ring increment), a measure of niche performance and correlated with intrinsic rate of increase, r .
Important findings I find that across 15 species, there are significantly more negative correlations than expected by chance. This negative correlation between abundance and performance across space contradicts common assumptions but is consistent with an inclusive niche structuring of the community.

Key words: tree rings, biogeography, inclusive niche, climate change

摘要：
Aims A common assumption in ecology is that where a species is found to be most abundant must correspond to the environmental context in which the species performs the best (i.e. optimal niche space). This assumption is central to common conservation and management tools such as habitat suitability assessment and species distribution modeling. I test this hypothesis.
Methods I use the US Forest Inventory Assessment data for the abundance of trees across eastern North America. I use the FORAST tree-ring dataset for ontogenetic growth rate (tree-ring increment), a measure of niche performance and correlated with intrinsic rate of increase, r .
Important findings I find that across 15 species, there are significantly more negative correlations than expected by chance. This negative correlation between abundance and performance across space contradicts common assumptions but is consistent with an inclusive niche structuring of the community.

Brian J. McGill. Trees are rarely most abundant where they grow best[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2012, 5(1): 46-51.

[1]	Mingyang Liu, Weiren Wang, Qing Ye, Hui Liu, Ronghua Li, Shidan Zhu, Osazee O Oyanoghafo, Pengcheng He. Trade-offs between water use efficiency and hydraulic conductivity across 52 woody species distributed in three forests along a precipitation gradient [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[2]	Hanliang Gui, Xuewen Zhou, Zixuan Li, Qinchuan Xin. Overestimated carbon uptake stability due to inadequate vegetation dynamics in ecosystem models [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[3]	Siyuan Gao, Yifan Gao, Huimin Zhou, Chunyan Lu, Xinxin Wang, Ying Chen, Hao Wang, Chengcheng Dong, Huiying Liu. Soil multifunctionality in the face of climate change and human impact across China’s drylands [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[4]	Na Li, Suke Hou, Mai-He Li, Xi Qi, Liangjun Zhu, Jitang Li, Paolo Cherubini, Zhaoyong Hu, Zhengfang Wu, Renkai Dong, Lei Wang, Youwen Wang, Danyang Yuan, Haibo Du. Elevation gradient modulates the effects of herbaceous encroachment on the long-term growth trends and climate sensitivity of Rhododendron aureum in alpine tundra [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[5]	Ke Zhang, Feng Zhang, Xian-Qi Zhou, Qing-Pu Wang, Zi-Ying Wang, Sheng-Mei Li, Yao-Ming Li, Shi-Kui Dong. Geographical and climatic drivers of phyllosphere microbiota in alpine grasslands on the Qinghai–Tibetan Plateau [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-0.
[6]	Yikang Cheng, Zhen Zhang, Hao Xu, Shurong Zhou. Climate factors and island area drive leaf economic trait variation by altering plant species richness and soil properties on tropical islands [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-0.
[7]	Shuo Zhang, Ya-Jie Zhou, Jia-Na Lin, Wen Qin, Ting Zhou, Shao-Lin Peng. Potential effects of future climate change on global Taxus distributions and diversity [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[8]	Gianalberto Losapio, Lucía Mottet, Nora Khelidj, Bao Ngan Tu, Bruno E.L. Cerabolini, Stephanie Grand, Natasha de Vere, Antoine Guisan. Ecological indicators predict functional diversity dynamics following glacier retreat [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-37.
[9]	Jiaqi Guo, Zihan Zhou, Tong Feng, Jincheng Liu, Jun Liu, Xiaomin Zeng. Prediction of potential suitable areas for dominant tree species in China under future climate change scenarios [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-53.
[10]	Meng-Qiu Niu, Mei-Hong Huang, Peng-Fei Yang, Quan-Sheng Fu, Jie Lin, Junyi Chen, Tao Zhang, Zhi-Min Li, Zhou-Yu Liao, Hang Sun, Jian-Guo Chen. Multiple cushion plants enhance alpine plant diversity through sustaining plant–plant co-occurrence networks [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-48.
[11]	Qiaoyu Yan, Xuming Wang, Ashraf Muhammad Arslan, Runji Ma, Qi Liu, Lei Li, Xiaoying Gong. Electron transport to assimilation ratio (ETR/A) of C₃ plants is affected by atmospheric CO₂ [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-34.
[12]	Enze Li, Hang Luo, Xingyong Cui, Kangjia Liu, Wenpan Dong. Future climate change promotes the global threat of the emerald ash borer (Agrilus planipennis Fairmaire) to ash species [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-26.
[13]	Wenjie Li, Chenrui Wang, Peng Zhang, Junsheng Ke, Zijian Yu, Yilin Dang, Hongying Jiang, Mu Liu, Kui Hu, Xiang Liu. Higher leaf positions associated with biotrophic pathogen infection [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-35.
[14]	Nan Wang, Ayong Jiao, Yingjun Xu, Yacun Yang, Nan Cong, Weiwei Yao. Divergent responses of vegetation phenology and productivity to climate change in typical river basins across Northern and Southern China [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(4): 1-.
[15]	Xiao-Hui Zhou, Wei-Ming He, Pei-Hao Peng, Jing-Ji Li. Long-term warming legacies facilitate invasive plant growth and inhibit enemy performance [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-16.