Pollinators exert positive selection on flower size on urban, but not on rural Scotch broom (Cytisus scoparius L. Link)

doi:10.1093/jpe/rtx024

Abstract

Abstract: Aims Adaptive evolution of invasive species is both particularly exciting for the evolutionary biologist and worrisome for those interested in controlling or halting spread. Invasive species often have a distinct timeline and well-recorded population expansion. As invaders encounter new environments, they undergo rapid adaptive evolution. Our aim in this study was to measure variation of floral size in the invasive shrub Cytisus scoparius (Scotch broom) and measure natural selection by pollinators on that trait. Past research has found that this invasive plant is pollinator limited in Washington State and that declines in pollinator populations can contribute to local extinction in another invaded range (New Zealand). This plant is pollinated by both native and introduced species of bees, representing a broad range of pollinator sizes. Cytisus scoparius has a flower structure that is highly conducive to studies on pollinator choice, even in the absence of direct pollinator observations.
Methods We surveyed urban and rural sites in and around the city of Olympia in Washington State. Measuring banner width, we were able to show that flower size varies substantially between plants but minimally within plants. By measuring the proportion of flowers that were 'tripped', we could determine pollinator visitation rates and thus determine the level of selection due to pollinator choice alone.
Important findings We found that C. scoparius is under natural selection by pollinators for increased flower size. However, such positive natural selection was only seen in urban populations although it was consistent across two flowering seasons. Rural populations of Scotch broom do not appear to be under selection on flower size. The natural selection by pollinators on broom flowers could result in adaptive evolution into a new pollination niche by an invading species. A higher level of variation in broom flowers seen here than seen in previous works in native regions suggests that C. scoparius may be highly diverse and primed for adaptive evolution.

Key words: invasive, evolution, pollinator, selection, flower

摘要：
Aims Adaptive evolution of invasive species is both particularly exciting for the evolutionary biologist and worrisome for those interested in controlling or halting spread. Invasive species often have a distinct timeline and well-recorded population expansion. As invaders encounter new environments, they undergo rapid adaptive evolution. Our aim in this study was to measure variation of floral size in the invasive shrub Cytisus scoparius (Scotch broom) and measure natural selection by pollinators on that trait. Past research has found that this invasive plant is pollinator limited in Washington State and that declines in pollinator populations can contribute to local extinction in another invaded range (New Zealand). This plant is pollinated by both native and introduced species of bees, representing a broad range of pollinator sizes. Cytisus scoparius has a flower structure that is highly conducive to studies on pollinator choice, even in the absence of direct pollinator observations.
Methods We surveyed urban and rural sites in and around the city of Olympia in Washington State. Measuring banner width, we were able to show that flower size varies substantially between plants but minimally within plants. By measuring the proportion of flowers that were 'tripped', we could determine pollinator visitation rates and thus determine the level of selection due to pollinator choice alone.
Important findings We found that C. scoparius is under natural selection by pollinators for increased flower size. However, such positive natural selection was only seen in urban populations although it was consistent across two flowering seasons. Rural populations of Scotch broom do not appear to be under selection on flower size. The natural selection by pollinators on broom flowers could result in adaptive evolution into a new pollination niche by an invading species. A higher level of variation in broom flowers seen here than seen in previous works in native regions suggests that C. scoparius may be highly diverse and primed for adaptive evolution.

Robert Frederick, Bode Rebecca Tong. Pollinators exert positive selection on flower size on urban, but not on rural Scotch broom (Cytisus scoparius L. Link)[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2018, 11(3): 493-501.

[1]	Mingli Ding, Yao Wei, Yuzhang Li, Jianyu Ma, Jingya Zhang, Jiangqin Song, Huiying Liu, Hao Wang, Zhenhua Zhang. Trait-reproductive allocation pathways of different flowering groups under seasonal drought in alpine meadows [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[2]	Chenxin Miao, Jun Du, Wen Wang, Juanjuan Wu, Longqing Wu, Kehai Zhang, Xuee Ma, Heng Ren. Inter-annual climate variability reshapes the spatial matching of plant and pollinators: evidence from a native invasive species [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-37.
[3]	Mingli Wei, Jingwei Guo, Runhao Liu, Juan Xuan, Zhenxing Zhou, Zhongling Yang, Anqun Chen, Yinzhan Liu. Growing and non-growing seasons warming interactively affect plant phenology in semi-arid steppe [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[4]	Yingcheng Wang, Junbang Wang, Chu Wu, Huakun Zhou, Miao Zhang, Bo Zhao, Xi Peng, Xingsheng Yang, Xin Jin, Zhuohang Zhang, Guangxin Lu, Ye Deng. Selective recruitment of core rhizobacterial communities with distinct life-history strategies by two grass genera [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-41.
[5]	Lifeng Zhou, Yige Zhao, Bernhard Schmid, Arjen Biere, Lin Jiang, Hongwei Yu, Mengqi Wang, Wandong Yin, Yu Shi, Jianqing Ding. Genetic variation in leaf chemistry driven by herbivory affects phyllosphere fungal communities in an invasive plant [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-44.
[6]	Ting-Ting Liu, Dan-Dan Zhang, Meng-Ying He, Jin-Sheng Li, Hong-Miao Wu, Wen-Yu Jiang, Yi-Yi Long, Xu-Rui Zhu, Zhen Zhang. Effects of different intensities of artificial light at night on functional traits of invasive and native plants [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-14.
[7]	Zhilong Zhao, Jinyang Yu, Wenxuan Zhao, Miao Ma, Jieshi Tang. Intraspecific differentiation and phenotypic plasticity help the invasive success of Xanthium italicum [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-31.
[8]	Ivan M. De-la-Cruz, Femke Batsleer, Dries Bonte, Carolina Diller, José Luis Izquierdo, Sonja Still, Sonia Osorio, David Posé, Aurora de la Rosa, Martijn L. Vandegehuchte, Anne Muola, Timo Hytönen, Johan A. Stenberg. Flowering responses of the woodland strawberry to local climate and reduced precipitation along a European latitudinal gradient [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-14.
[9]	Sissi Lozada-Gobilard, M. Kate Gallagher, Roni Heliczer, Omer Bar, Mahua Ghara, Yamit Bar-Lev, Marjan Kraaij, Casper J. van der Kooi, Ilan Koren, Yuval Sapir. Flower display and temperature in Royal irises (Iris section Oncocyclus, Iridaceae) [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(5): 1-16.
[10]	Fanjiao Kong, Dingli Wang, Yu Shi, Liya Ma, Jianqing Ding. Variation in niche effects on microbiota in two invasive plants [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(4): 1-16.
[11]	Ciara Matos, David Ward. Invasive grass species do not have priority effects [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(4): 1-39.
[12]	Qian-Wei Li, Jun-Qin Gao, Yu-Xi Guo, Jin-Feng Liang, Fei-Hai Yu. Effects of biochar on nitrogen competition between invasive Spartina alterniflora and native Phragmites australis [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(4): 1-35.
[13]	Xiao Guo, Huijia Song, Pan Wu, Lele Liu, Mingyan Li, Liujuan Xie, Emil Jespersen, Siyuan Ye, Weihua Guo. Intraspecific variation in plant elementome reflects environment more than genetic and epigenetic variation within a widespread grass (Phragmites australis) [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(4): 1-31.
[14]	Julia Dieskau, Isabell Hensen, Nico Eisenhauer, Susanne Lachmuth, Harald Auge. Plant–soil feedback in European grasslands is phylogenetically independent but affected by plant species origin [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-12.
[15]	Lei Wang, Muhammad Hasnain, Zhanhui Tang, Kobayashi Makoto. Soil water availability alters plant‐soil feedback effects on invasive plant growth and foliar herbivory [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-13.