The ecological performance of metallophyte plants thriving in geochemical islands is explained by the Inclusive Niche Hypothesis

doi:10.1093/jpe/rtu007

Abstract

Abstract: Aims The Inclusive Niche Hypothesis has not been validated for plants using ecophysiological performance. The few experiments have measured growth and competition but not the physiological response of plants. A metallophyte plant that hyperaccumulates aluminium (Al), Plantago almogravensis, showed a defined spatial distribution by occurring mostly on vegetation gaps associated with metalliferous areas (geochemical islands). This case was used to determine, in situ, whether the Inclusive Niche Hypothesis was suitable to explain the extent of the species realized niche.
Methods The vegetation associated with P. almogravensis geochemical islands in the SW coast of Portugal was mapped. The biotic (neighbouring plants) and abiotic (edaphic) components of the niche were correlated with parameters of the plant's ecological and physiological performances (plant density and cover; leaf C and N concentration and isotopic composition; growth). The results were obtained using image analysis, abundance and morphological measures, isotopic signatures and chemical composition.
Important findings The species showed better physiological performance where its ecological performance was lower due to trade-offs with environmental constraints. The species' realized niche was mostly limited by shrub competition and soil Al-toxicity. These limits contribute to explain the rarity status of the species: the species has a poor capacity to compete but, due to an enhanced Al-tolerance and Al-hyperaccumulator trait, has the ability to find refuge in geochemical islands that are too harsh for most other species. This work, based on ecophysiological field studies, provides support for the Inclusive Niche Hypothesis relating to plant species.

Key words: competition, ecophysiology, edaphic endemism, hyperaccumulation, stable isotopes, trade-off

摘要：
Aims The Inclusive Niche Hypothesis has not been validated for plants using ecophysiological performance. The few experiments have measured growth and competition but not the physiological response of plants. A metallophyte plant that hyperaccumulates aluminium (Al), Plantago almogravensis, showed a defined spatial distribution by occurring mostly on vegetation gaps associated with metalliferous areas (geochemical islands). This case was used to determine, in situ, whether the Inclusive Niche Hypothesis was suitable to explain the extent of the species realized niche.
Methods The vegetation associated with P. almogravensis geochemical islands in the SW coast of Portugal was mapped. The biotic (neighbouring plants) and abiotic (edaphic) components of the niche were correlated with parameters of the plant's ecological and physiological performances (plant density and cover; leaf C and N concentration and isotopic composition; growth). The results were obtained using image analysis, abundance and morphological measures, isotopic signatures and chemical composition.
Important findings The species showed better physiological performance where its ecological performance was lower due to trade-offs with environmental constraints. The species' realized niche was mostly limited by shrub competition and soil Al-toxicity. These limits contribute to explain the rarity status of the species: the species has a poor capacity to compete but, due to an enhanced Al-tolerance and Al-hyperaccumulator trait, has the ability to find refuge in geochemical islands that are too harsh for most other species. This work, based on ecophysiological field studies, provides support for the Inclusive Niche Hypothesis relating to plant species.

Helena C. Serrano, Cristina Antunes, Manuel J. Pinto, Cristina Máguas, Maria Amélia Martins-Loução, Cristina Branquinho. The ecological performance of metallophyte plants thriving in geochemical islands is explained by the Inclusive Niche Hypothesis[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2015, 8(1): 41-50.

[1]	Yaobing Qu, Tianzi Qin, Xinjian Shi, Jing Chen, Hui Liu, Nianxi Zhao, Yubao Gao and Anzhi Ren. The effects of Epichloë endophytes on the growth and competitiveness of Achnatherum sibiricum are mediated by soil microbe diversity [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2023, 16(1): 0-.
[2]	Youli Yu, Huiyuan Cheng, Shu Wang, Mei Wei, Congyan Wang, and Daolin Du. Drought may be beneficial to the competitive advantage of Amaranthus spinosus [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2022, 15(3): 494-508.
[3]	Zhiyuan Hu, Jiaqi Zhang, Yizhou Du, Kangwei Shi, Guangqian Ren, Babar Iqbal, Zhicong Dai, Jian Li, Guanlin Li and Daolin Du. Substrate availability regulates the suppressive effects of Canada goldenrod invasion on soil respiration [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2022, 15(3): 509-523.
[4]	Wei-Ping Zhang, Dario Fornara, Guang-Cai Liu, Josep Peñuelas, Jordi Sardans, Jian-Hao Sun, Li-Zhen Zhang and Long Li. Interspecific interactions affect N and P uptake rather than N:P ratios of plant species: evidence from intercropping [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2022, 15(2): 223-236.
[5]	Yun Guo, Yuejun He, Pan Wu, Bangli Wu, Yan Lin, Minhong He, Xu Han, Tingting Xia, Kaiping Shen, Liling Kang, Qiyu Tan, Wenda Ren, Yan Sun and Qing Li. The interspecific competition presents greater nutrient facilitation compared with intraspecific competition through AM fungi interacting with litter for two host plants in karst soil [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2022, 15(2): 399-412.
[6]	Miao Liu, Helena Korpelainen and Chunyang Li. Sexual differences and sex ratios of dioecious plants under stressful environments [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(5): 920-933.
[7]	Christian Damgaard, and Jacob Weiner. The need for alternative plant species interaction models [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(5): 771-780.
[8]	Xi Luo, Loralee Larios, Carla D’Antonio, Xiaohong Xu and Hui Guo. An invading annual plant benefits less from soil biota and has reduced competitive power with a resident grass [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(5): 945-958.
[9]	Alyssa Laney Smith, Daniel Z. Atwater, Wonjae Kim, David C. Haak and Jacob N. Barney. Invasive plant rhizome production and competitiveness vary based on neighbor identity [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(4): 638-647.
[10]	Ricardo Sánchez-Martín, José Maria Gómez, Pierre-Olivier Cheptou and Rafael Rubio de Casas. Differences in seed dormancy and germination in amphicarpic legumes: manifold bet-hedging in space and time [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(4): 662-672.
[11]	Dan-Dan Li, Hong-Wei Nan, Chun-Zhang Zhao, Chun-Ying Yin and Qing Liu. Effects of warming and fertilization interacting with intraspecific competition on fine root traits of Picea asperata [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(1): 147-159.
[12]	Xi Luo, Yi Zheng, Xiaohong Xu, Rui Xiao and Hui Guo. The impacts of warming and nitrogen addition on competitive ability of native and invasive populations of Plantago virginica [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(6): 676-682.
[13]	Yan Li, Jieyu Kang, Zhijun Li, Helena Korpelainen and Chunyang Li. Ecophysiological responses of two poplar species to intraspecific and interspecific competition under different nitrogen levels [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(6): 693-703.
[14]	Ming-Hua Song, Johannes H.C. Cornelissen, Yi-Kang Li, Xing-Liang Xu, Hua-Kun Zhou, Xiao-Yong Cui, Yan-Fen Wang, Rong-Yan Xu and Qi Feng. Small-scale switch in cover–perimeter relationships of patches indicates shift of dominant species during grassland degradation [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(6): 704-712.
[15]	Nara O. Vogado, Michael J. Liddell, Susan G. W. Laurance , Mason J. Campbell, Alexander W. Cheesman , Jayden E. Engert, Ana C. Palma , Françoise Y. Ishida and Lucas A. Cernusak. The effects of an experimental drought on the ecophysiology and fruiting phenology of a tropical rainforest palm [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(6): 744-753.