Plant responses to simulated warming and drought: a comparative study of functional plasticity between congeneric mid and high elevation species

doi:10.1093/jpe/rtx023

Abstract

Abstract: Aims Effects of climate change, especially changes in temperatures and precipitation patterns, are particularly pronounced in alpine regions. In response, plants may exhibit phenotypic plasticity in key functional traits allowing short-term adjustment to novel conditions. However, little is known about the degree of phenotypic plasticity of high elevation species relative to mid elevation congeners.
Methods We transplanted 14 herbaceous perennial species from high elevation into two common gardens (1050 and 2000 m.a.s.l.) in the Swiss Alps, and we examined plastic responses in key functional traits to changes in temperature and soil water availability. This design was replicated with 14 congeneric species from mid elevation to assess if the degree of phenotypic plasticity differs between mid and high elevation species. Survival was assessed across two growing seasons, while aboveground biomass and specific leaf area (SLA) were measured after the first growing season, and biomass allocation to belowground and reproductive structures after the second. Moreover, a phenotypic plasticity index was calculated for the functional traits to compare the degree of plasticity between mid and high elevation species.
Important findings Aboveground biomass was higher in mid elevation species relative to high elevation congeners in all treatments, yet decreased for both with elevation and drought. Similarly, SLA decreased with elevation and drought. Root mass fraction (RMF) was generally higher in high elevation species, and decreased with drought at the lower site. Drought increased the allocation to reproductive structures, especially when plants were grown at their elevation of origin. Interestingly, no difference was found in the degree of phenotypic plasticity averaged across mid and high elevation species for any of the studied functional traits. These results indicate that phenotypic plasticity in the focal traits did not depend on the elevation of origin of the species. Plasticity was not related to environmental heterogeneity, nor constrained by selective pressures at high elevation. However, both species groups showed a remarkable capacity for short-term acclimation to a prospective climate through rapid adjustments in key functional traits.

Key words: biomass allocation, common garden, climate change, perennial herbaceous species, phenotypic plasticity, SLA, Swiss Alps, transplant experiment

摘要：
Aims Effects of climate change, especially changes in temperatures and precipitation patterns, are particularly pronounced in alpine regions. In response, plants may exhibit phenotypic plasticity in key functional traits allowing short-term adjustment to novel conditions. However, little is known about the degree of phenotypic plasticity of high elevation species relative to mid elevation congeners.
Methods We transplanted 14 herbaceous perennial species from high elevation into two common gardens (1050 and 2000 m.a.s.l.) in the Swiss Alps, and we examined plastic responses in key functional traits to changes in temperature and soil water availability. This design was replicated with 14 congeneric species from mid elevation to assess if the degree of phenotypic plasticity differs between mid and high elevation species. Survival was assessed across two growing seasons, while aboveground biomass and specific leaf area (SLA) were measured after the first growing season, and biomass allocation to belowground and reproductive structures after the second. Moreover, a phenotypic plasticity index was calculated for the functional traits to compare the degree of plasticity between mid and high elevation species.
Important findings Aboveground biomass was higher in mid elevation species relative to high elevation congeners in all treatments, yet decreased for both with elevation and drought. Similarly, SLA decreased with elevation and drought. Root mass fraction (RMF) was generally higher in high elevation species, and decreased with drought at the lower site. Drought increased the allocation to reproductive structures, especially when plants were grown at their elevation of origin. Interestingly, no difference was found in the degree of phenotypic plasticity averaged across mid and high elevation species for any of the studied functional traits. These results indicate that phenotypic plasticity in the focal traits did not depend on the elevation of origin of the species. Plasticity was not related to environmental heterogeneity, nor constrained by selective pressures at high elevation. However, both species groups showed a remarkable capacity for short-term acclimation to a prospective climate through rapid adjustments in key functional traits.

Elena Hamann, Halil Kesselring, Jürg Stöcklin. Plant responses to simulated warming and drought: a comparative study of functional plasticity between congeneric mid and high elevation species[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2018, 11(3): 364-374.

[1]	Mingyang Liu, Weiren Wang, Qing Ye, Hui Liu, Ronghua Li, Shidan Zhu, Osazee O Oyanoghafo, Pengcheng He. Trade-offs between water use efficiency and hydraulic conductivity across 52 woody species distributed in three forests along a precipitation gradient [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[2]	Hanliang Gui, Xuewen Zhou, Zixuan Li, Qinchuan Xin. Overestimated carbon uptake stability due to inadequate vegetation dynamics in ecosystem models [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[3]	Mingli Ding, Yao Wei, Yuzhang Li, Jianyu Ma, Jingya Zhang, Jiangqin Song, Huiying Liu, Hao Wang, Zhenhua Zhang. Trait-reproductive allocation pathways of different flowering groups under seasonal drought in alpine meadows [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[4]	Qing Wei, Chang-Fan Chen, Cheng-Gang Qiu, Ning-Fei Lei, Jin-Song Chen, Yong-Mei Liao. Combined plasticity within and between generations increases drought resistance more in a clonal, introduced, invasive plant than its native congener [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[5]	Li Chen, Amparo Lázaro, Haidong Li, Zhibin Tao, Jun Yin, Mingchuan Zhong, Guangtao Meng, Pinrong Li, Sheng Qiu, Dezhu Li, Hong Wang, Yanhui Zhao. Aggressive native plant disrupts plant-arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi networks in subalpine meadows [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[6]	Naeem Ullah Khalil, Wan-Yue Zhu, Xin-Ying Dou, Sehrish Mahroof, Ya-Nan Li, Hai-Yan Li, Jian-Yong Wang. Clipping-induced compensatory growth response of Leymus chinensis clones mediated by nitrogen availability under heterogeneous environments [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[7]	Siyuan Gao, Yifan Gao, Huimin Zhou, Chunyan Lu, Xinxin Wang, Ying Chen, Hao Wang, Chengcheng Dong, Huiying Liu. Soil multifunctionality in the face of climate change and human impact across China’s drylands [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[8]	Na Li, Suke Hou, Mai-He Li, Xi Qi, Liangjun Zhu, Jitang Li, Paolo Cherubini, Zhaoyong Hu, Zhengfang Wu, Renkai Dong, Lei Wang, Youwen Wang, Danyang Yuan, Haibo Du. Elevation gradient modulates the effects of herbaceous encroachment on the long-term growth trends and climate sensitivity of Rhododendron aureum in alpine tundra [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[9]	Xiao-Hua Yang, Xiao-Sa Liang, Yuan Shi, Yuan-Xiu Wu, Xiao-Ru Zhang, Cong Ding, Xiao-Jing Zhang, Alemayehu Adugna, Xiao-Tao Lü. Grassland plant species with slow-growing strategy are more resistant to extreme drought [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[10]	Mingli Wei, Jingwei Guo, Runhao Liu, Juan Xuan, Zhenxing Zhou, Zhongling Yang, Anqun Chen, Yinzhan Liu. Growing and non-growing seasons warming interactively affect plant phenology in semi-arid steppe [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[11]	Yu An, Yang Gao, Jian Liu, Yuqi Zhang, Duojia Wang, Hongyuan Ma, Shouzheng Tong. Plant community root traits outweigh target species in mediating soil carbon and nitrogen storage across grazing-exclusion chronosequences in semi-arid grasslands [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[12]	Chang’an Guo, Ziwei Wang, Xiulong Zhang, Yu Yang, Yuangyuan Tang, Weikai Bao. Confronting allometric and optimal partitioning theories in biomass allocation: evidence from Artemisia species along an elevational gradient in Southwest of China [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[13]	Jiaojiao Wang, Fei Zang, Ruochun Wang, Fangyuan Huang , Wenfang Zeng, Hu Hao, Chuanyan Zhao. Accumulation and translocation of trace elements in plant-soil systems of the Qilian Mountains grassland under climate warming [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[14]	Ke Zhang, Feng Zhang, Xian-Qi Zhou, Qing-Pu Wang, Zi-Ying Wang, Sheng-Mei Li, Yao-Ming Li, Shi-Kui Dong. Geographical and climatic drivers of phyllosphere microbiota in alpine grasslands on the Qinghai–Tibetan Plateau [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-0.
[15]	Yikang Cheng, Zhen Zhang, Hao Xu, Shurong Zhou. Climate factors and island area drive leaf economic trait variation by altering plant species richness and soil properties on tropical islands [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-0.