Asymmetric competition for light varies across functional groups

doi:10.1093/jpe/rtw114

Abstract

Abstract: Aims Asymmetric competition for light may depress the growth rates (GRs) to different extents for different-sized tree individuals. Various responses of different functional groups to light availability result that tree individuals of different functional groups may experience different competition intensities, e.g. canopy and deciduous species grow faster and demand more light than understory and evergreen species. In this study, we estimated the effects of asymmetric competition for light using individual GRs and explored the effects of asymmetric competition on growth among different functional groups (e.g. canopy vs. understory species and deciduous vs. evergreen species).
Methods We measured growth in circumference to determine the radial increments of a total of 2233 stems with diameter at breast height ≥ 5.0 cm in a permanent plot (140 × 80 m 2) located in a typical evergreen and deciduous broadleaved mixed forest on Mt Shennongjia, China. All of the measurements were carried out at ~6-month intervals every April and October from 2012 to 2014, and biomass of each individual was calculated based on its diameter and species-specific allometry. We then calculated GRs of annual biomass growth (growth between October and the next October). Considering the hypothesis that asymmetric competition for light among trees of different sizes may result in a steeper allometric growth curve with increasing tree size, we further divided the sampled trees into different subsets according to their height, at intervals of 1 m, and then fitted the scaling relationship between the logarithm of the biomass GR (logGR) and the logarithm of diameter (logD) for each height class using standardized major axis regression. Finally, we used simple linear regression to test whether the scaling exponent was related to tree height. The above analyses were conducted for the annual growth of all tree species, canopy species, understory vs. treelets species and deciduous vs. evergreen species.
Important findings We observed a concave curve for the relationship between logGR and logD with an increase in the scaling exponent between logGR and logD with increasing tree height. This pattern held for the annual growth of canopy species and deciduous species but not for the annual growth of understory species, treelets or evergreen species. These results suggest that asymmetric competition for light is more important in regulating the GRs of the fast-growing species, such as canopy species and deciduous species, than those of shade-tolerant species, such as understory species, treelets and evergreen species.

Key words: asymmetric competition, tree height, metabolic scaling theory, tree growth, functional group

摘要：
Aims Asymmetric competition for light may depress the growth rates (GRs) to different extents for different-sized tree individuals. Various responses of different functional groups to light availability result that tree individuals of different functional groups may experience different competition intensities, e.g. canopy and deciduous species grow faster and demand more light than understory and evergreen species. In this study, we estimated the effects of asymmetric competition for light using individual GRs and explored the effects of asymmetric competition on growth among different functional groups (e.g. canopy vs. understory species and deciduous vs. evergreen species).
Methods We measured growth in circumference to determine the radial increments of a total of 2233 stems with diameter at breast height ≥ 5.0 cm in a permanent plot (140 × 80 m 2) located in a typical evergreen and deciduous broadleaved mixed forest on Mt Shennongjia, China. All of the measurements were carried out at ~6-month intervals every April and October from 2012 to 2014, and biomass of each individual was calculated based on its diameter and species-specific allometry. We then calculated GRs of annual biomass growth (growth between October and the next October). Considering the hypothesis that asymmetric competition for light among trees of different sizes may result in a steeper allometric growth curve with increasing tree size, we further divided the sampled trees into different subsets according to their height, at intervals of 1 m, and then fitted the scaling relationship between the logarithm of the biomass GR (logGR) and the logarithm of diameter (logD) for each height class using standardized major axis regression. Finally, we used simple linear regression to test whether the scaling exponent was related to tree height. The above analyses were conducted for the annual growth of all tree species, canopy species, understory vs. treelets species and deciduous vs. evergreen species.
Important findings We observed a concave curve for the relationship between logGR and logD with an increase in the scaling exponent between logGR and logD with increasing tree height. This pattern held for the annual growth of canopy species and deciduous species but not for the annual growth of understory species, treelets or evergreen species. These results suggest that asymmetric competition for light is more important in regulating the GRs of the fast-growing species, such as canopy species and deciduous species, than those of shade-tolerant species, such as understory species, treelets and evergreen species.

Qiang Guo, Xiulian Chi, Zongqiang Xie, Zhiyao Tang. Asymmetric competition for light varies across functional groups[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2017, 10(1): 74-80.

[1]	Mingli Ding, Yao Wei, Yuzhang Li, Jianyu Ma, Jingya Zhang, Jiangqin Song, Huiying Liu, Hao Wang, Zhenhua Zhang. Trait-reproductive allocation pathways of different flowering groups under seasonal drought in alpine meadows [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(3): 1-.
[2]	Junjiong Shao, Xuhui Zhou, Lingyan Zhou, Yan Li. Plant biomass-leaf area allometry and ambient plant traits predict biomass responses to global warming [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-15.
[3]	Chengjie Gao, Zhongmu Li, Yong Chai, Jin Li, Kai Cui. Slope position affects growth and allometry of Calocedrus macrolepis by mediating soil properties and microbial communities [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-17.
[4]	Yuhan Liu, Yifei Zhao, Qiaosheng Li, Zijun Tan, Zugeng Zhang, Yuxuan Liu, Jianming Wang, Congcong Liu, Chunwang Xiao. Variation in leaf construction cost and environmental drivers in China [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(2): 1-14.
[5]	Bingqian Su, Wenlong Xu, Zhuoxia Su, Zhouping Shangguan. Machine learning applications to reveal the difference in Robinia pseudoacacia growth and its drivers on China’s Loess Plateau [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(1): 1-16.
[6]	Lu Bai, Lei Tian, Zhiguo Ren, Xiaohui Song, Kailiang Yu, Lin Meng, Zhanfeng Hou, Haiyan Ren. Climate warming advances plant reproductive phenology in China’s northern grasslands [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2024, 17(6): 1-.
[7]	Xiang Song, Jinxu Li, Xiaodong Zeng. Parameterization of height-diameter and crown radius-diameter relationships across the globe [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2024, 17(2): 0-rtae005.
[8]	Yumeng Guo, Meng Zhou, Jun Sheng, Yujia Yuan, Guangyuan Yuan, Wen-Hao Zhang, Wenming Bai. Aboveground net primary productivity was not limited by phosphorus in a temperate typical steppe in Inner Mongolia [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2023, 16(4): 0-rtac085.
[9]	Bowen Li, Jianping Sun, Shiping Wang, Wangwang Lv, Yang Zhou, Peipei Liu, Qi Wang, Wang A, Suren Zhang, Lu Xia, Huan Hong, Lili Jiang, Caiyun Luo, Zhenhua Zhang, Shilong Piao, Yanfen Wang, Tsechoe Dorji. Greater responses of flower phenology of Kobresia pygmaea community to precipitation addition than to constant and stepwise warming [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2023, 16(2): 0-rtac066.
[10]	Jie Liu, Zong-Shan Li, Maierdang Keyimu, Xiaochun Wang, Haibin Liang, Xiaoming Feng, Guangyao Gao and Bojie Fu. Accelerated warming in the late 20th century promoted tree radial growth in the Northern Hemisphere [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2023, 16(1): 0-.
[11]	Xingchang Wang, Qi Wang, Yue Chen, Rui Zhao, Jiahui Zhang, Xiankui Quan, Fan Liu and Chuankuan Wang. Coloration and phenology manifest nutrient variability in senesced leaves of 46 temperate deciduous woody species [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2022, 15(4): 700-710.
[12]	Ruo-Nan Shen, Yang-Jian Zhang, Jun-Tao Zhu, Ning Chen, Yao Chen, Guang Zhao, Yi-Xuan Zhu, Ze Tang and Wen-Yu Li. The interactive effects of nitrogen addition and increased precipitation on gross ecosystem productivity in an alpine meadow [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2022, 15(1): 168-179.
[13]	Feng-Wei Xu, Jian-Jun Li, Ji-Shuai Su, Xiao-Ming Lu, Yang Wang, Li-Ji Wu, Chao-Nan Wang, Di-Ma Chen, and Yong-Fei Bai. Seasonality regulates the effects of resource addition on plant diversity and ecosystem functioning in semi-arid grassland [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(6): 1143-1157.
[14]	Lili Zheng, Narayan Prasad Gaire and Peili Shi. High-altitude tree growth responses to climate change across the Hindu Kush Himalaya [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(5): 829-842.
[15]	Zhi Zheng, Yue Zhang, Shihu Zhang, Qun Ma, Dajie Gong and Guoying Zhou. Above- and belowground trait linkages of dominant species shape responses of alpine steppe composition to precipitation changes in the Tibetan Plateau [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2021, 14(4): 569-579.