J Plant Ecol ›› Advance articles     DOI:10.1093/jpe/rtag151

• Research Article •     Next Articles

Soil nutrient-driven shifts in tree water use strategies in pure and mixed stands: insights from natural secondary forests

Wenbin Xua,b, Qing Xua,b*, Deqiang Gaoa,b, Haijun Zuoa, Ke Diaoa, Zhicheng Chena,b, Beibei Zhanga,b*   

  1. aKey Laboratory of Forest Ecology and Environment of National Forestry and Grassland Administration, Ecology and Nature Conservation Institute, Chinese Academy of Forestry, Beijing 100091, China
    bBaotianman Forest Ecosystem Research Station, Nanyang, Henan 474365, China
    *Corresponding author:
    Dr. Qing Xu, Email: xuqing@caf.ac.cn
    Dr. Beibei Zhang, Email: zhangbb@caf.ac.cn
  • Received:2026-02-04 Accepted:2026-06-16 Published:2026-06-30
  • Supported by:
    This research was funded by the National Key R&D Program of China (2021YFD2200401) and Fundamental Research Funds of CAF (CAFYBB2021ZE002; CAFYBB2024MA013).

土壤养分驱动下纯林与混交林树种水分利用策略差异:基于天然次生林的启示

Abstract: Understanding tree water use strategies under altered precipitation is vital for forest ecosystem management. However, most studies have focused on tree water use strategies at seasonal or monthly scales, while neglecting those following individual rainfall events. Here, we employed stable isotope (δD and δ18O) and Bayesian mixed model (MixSIAR) to quantify water use patterns of dominant trees in Quercus aliena, Pinus armandii pure forests, and Q. aliena-P. armandii mixed forests across light, moderate, and heavy rainfall events (7.9, 23.8, and 47.3 mm) in the northern subtropical-warm temperate transition zone of China. Furthermore, correlation analysis and structural equation modeling (SEM) were used to identify key regulatory factors. Our results showed that tree mixing exerted species-specific and precipitation-dependent effects on water use. Under light and moderate rain, tree mixing significantly increased the absorption proportion from 0-20 cm soil water (18.53-42.93% vs. 48.97-86.53%) by Q. aliena while reducing its reliance on subsoil water. Tree mixing only enhanced the absorption proportion from 0-20 cm soil layer by P. armandii under light rain (16.07% vs. 25.47%). SEM revealed that soil nutrients (total nitrogen and total phosphorus) served as the core drivers regulating tree water use patterns across pure and mixed forests. This study highlights the vital nutrient regulation of tree water use strategies, challenging the traditional view that tree water use controlled by soil water distribution. It provides theoretical support for stand structure optimization and adaptive forest management in climate transition zones.

Elucidating tree water use strategies in response to changing precipitation is critical for forest ecological management, yet studies examining the tree water uptake following individual rainfall events remains scarce. This study demonstrated that tree mixing significantly increased the absorption proportion from shallow soil water by Quercus aliena following light and moderate rainfall events, with soil nutrients emerging as the primary driver of the differences in water use strategies between pure and mixed stands.

Key words: Water use strategy, δD and δ18O, Natural secondary forest, Precipitation events, Tree mixing

摘要:
准确理解降水格局变化背景下树种的水分利用策略,对森林生态系统管理至关重要。然而,以往研究多关注季节或月份尺度的树种水分利用策略,忽视了单次降水事件后树种吸水策略。本研究以中国北亚热带-暖温带过渡区锐齿槲栎(Quercus aliena)纯林、华山松(Pinus armandii)纯林及锐齿槲栎-华山松混交林为研究对象,运用氢氧稳定同位素(δD和δ18O)与贝叶斯混合模型(MixSIAR),计算了不同量级降水事件后(7.9、23.8和47.3 mm)后优势树种的水分利用格局;并采用相关性分析与结构方程模型(SEM)识别关键调控因子。结果表明,小雨和中雨后,树种混交显著提高了锐齿槲栎对0-20 cm浅层土壤水的吸收比例(18.53-42.93% vs.48.97-86.53%),同时降低了其对下层土壤水的依赖。而树种混交仅在中雨后提升了华山松对0-20 cm层土壤水的吸收比例(16.07% vs.25.47%)。SEM结果进一步揭示,土壤养分(全氮、全磷)是调控纯林与混交林树种水分利用格局的核心驱动因子。本研究强调了土壤养分对树种水分利用策略的关键调控作用,挑战了“树木水分利用格局仅由土壤水分分布主导”的传统观点,为气候过渡区林分结构优化与适应性经营管理提供了理论依据。

关键词: 水分利用策略, 氢氧稳定同位素 (δD 和 δ18O), 天然次生林, 降水事件, 树种混交