J Plant Ecol ›› Advance articles     DOI:10.1093/jpe/rtag080

• Research Article •     Next Articles

Cost of early flowering and a compensation mechanism in Primula atrodentata

Yin-Mei Ma1,#, Yong-Peng Cha1,#,*, Lin Zhang2, Zhao-Li Tong1, Zi-Lin Xu3, David W. Inouye4,5,*, Zhi-Qiang Zhang1,*   

  1. 1State Key Laboratory of Vegetation Structure, Functions and Construction (VegLab), Yunnan Key Laboratory of Biological Adaptation, Conservation and Utilization, School of Ecology and Environmental Science, Yunnan University, Kunming 650500, Yunnan, China
    2State Key Laboratory of Tibetan Plateau Earth System, Resources and Environment (TPESRE), Institute of Tibetan Plateau Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China
    3The School of Ecology and Environment, Anhui Normal University, Wuhu 241002, Anhui, China
    4The Rocky Mountain Biological Laboratory, Post Office Box 519, Crested Butte, CO 81224, USA
    5Department of Biology, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA
    #These authors contributed equally to this work.
    *Corresponding authors: e-mail zq.zhang@ynu.edu.cn; yongpengcha@163.com; inouye@umd.edu
  • Received:2025-10-14 Accepted:2026-03-23 Published:2026-04-17
  • Supported by:
    This study was supported by Yunnan Fundamental Research Projects (202405AC350111; 202501AS070067), and the Joint Funds of the National Natural Science Foundation of China and Yunnan Provincial Government (U1202261).

白心球花报春早开花的代价与一种补偿机制

Abstract: While early flowering is generally favored by natural selection in plants, alpine species may risk pollination failure with advanced blooming, making selfing an effective reproductive strategy under pollen limitation. Thus, pollination variability during flowering could drive seasonal mating-system shifts, though this hypothesis awaits verification. We investigated Primula atrodentata, a distylous plant species with long flowering duration in southeastern Tibet, by conducting pollinator observations, floral trait measurements and pollination manipulation experiments across different flowering periods in three populations to examine temporal variation in reproductive success and mating system responses. Our results reveal nonlinear elevational patterns in pollinator visitation and selfing syndrome, with early-flowering individuals showing reduced pollinator interactions (leading to stronger pollen limitation and lower reproductive success) but enhanced selfing adaptations. Notably, self-incompatibility index correlated significantly with both pollinator visitation and selfing syndrome expression. This study represents a first step toward systematically investigating the seasonal shifts in mating system caused by phenological asynchrony. Expanding such research will be crucial for understanding plant adaptations to pollinator mismatch—a growing challenge driven by climate changes.

In high-mountain habitats, early-spring flowering plants often face pollination limitation and risk reproductive failure due to pollinator scarcity. Our study on Primula atrodentata shows that early-flowering individuals suffer higher reproductive costs from pollination deficiency, yet simultaneously exhibit a more pronounced selfing syndrome and greater self-compatibility, which compensate for such losses. These findings preliminarily suggest adaptive evolution to cope with reproductive challenges posed by phenological mismatches with pollinators under climate change.

Key words: alpine plant, breeding system, flowering phenology, herkogamy, pollen limitation, self-compatibility

摘要:
尽管早开花通常受到自然选择的青睐,但高山植物提前开花可能面临传粉失败的风险。 在花粉限制的情况下, 自交是植物可能采取的一种有效繁殖策略。因此, 由花期导致的传粉环境变化可能会驱动植物的交配系统在季节间发生转变,然而这一假说仍有待验证。本研究以藏东南地区早春开花、 花期较长的二型花柱植物白心球花报春(Primula atrodentata)为研究对象,在3个自然居群中通过传粉者观察、花部性状测量以及不同花期的授粉操控实验,探究了传粉拜访、 繁殖成功与交配系统特征对开花时间的动态响应。结果显示,传粉者访花频率与自交综合征均呈现非线性的海拔格局,即中海拔居群的传粉者访花频率比低和高海拔居群的更高,而自交综合征则相反。相较于盛花个体,早花个体因与传粉者互作减少,遭受更强的花粉限制并导致更低的繁殖成功,而其自交适应特征则趋于增强。此外,自交不亲和性指数与传粉者访花频率及自交综合征表达均呈显著相关。本研究为系统探究物候异步性引起的繁育系统季节性转变提供了典型案例, 并强调拓展此类研究对于理解植物如何适应气候变化下日益加剧的传粉者错配问题具有关键意义。

关键词: 高山植物, 繁育系统, 开花物候, 雌雄异位, 花粉限制, 自交亲和性