Effect of nitrogen addition, form and clipping on competitive interactions between grassland species

doi:10.1093/jpe/rtt039

Abstract

Abstract: Aims Although the effects of N addition on plant biomass are well understood, we know a lot less about the importance of N form even though some studies have shown different impacts from reduced and oxidized forms of N. Furthermore, responses to grazing are likely to interact with the response to N addition. This experiment investigates the interactive effects of N addition and form with clipping on competition between three grassland species.
Methods The three species (Anthoxanthum odoratum L., Plantago lanceolata L. and Prunella vulgaris L.) were grown alone and in combination with factorial additions of deionized water, sodium nitrate and ammonium chloride, and a clipping treatment. Above- and belowground biomass was harvested after 4 months.
Important findings In monocultures, the results show increases in biomass with N addition, but clipping resulted in fewer changes with species displaying varying degrees of growth compensation. A. odoratum was the strongest competitor when grown with other species. In monocultures without clipping, N form was not important, but in the presence of clipping and in different species combinations, N form became important. Significant two- and three-way interactive effects were observed showing that complex interactions exist between N addition, clipping and species identity. The results have important implications when considering the effects of N deposition.

Key words: aboveground biomass, ammonium, grazing, nitrate, root biomass

摘要：
Aims Although the effects of N addition on plant biomass are well understood, we know a lot less about the importance of N form even though some studies have shown different impacts from reduced and oxidized forms of N. Furthermore, responses to grazing are likely to interact with the response to N addition. This experiment investigates the interactive effects of N addition and form with clipping on competition between three grassland species.
Methods The three species (Anthoxanthum odoratum L., Plantago lanceolata L. and Prunella vulgaris L.) were grown alone and in combination with factorial additions of deionized water, sodium nitrate and ammonium chloride, and a clipping treatment. Above- and belowground biomass was harvested after 4 months.
Important findings In monocultures, the results show increases in biomass with N addition, but clipping resulted in fewer changes with species displaying varying degrees of growth compensation. A. odoratum was the strongest competitor when grown with other species. In monocultures without clipping, N form was not important, but in the presence of clipping and in different species combinations, N form became important. Significant two- and three-way interactive effects were observed showing that complex interactions exist between N addition, clipping and species identity. The results have important implications when considering the effects of N deposition.

Carly J. Stevens, David J. G. Gowing. Effect of nitrogen addition, form and clipping on competitive interactions between grassland species[J]. J Plant Ecol, 2014, 7(3): 222-230.

[1]	Qian Liu, Xiaolin Zhu, Nan Jiang, Lihao Zhang, Shiyuan Wu, Ge Meng, Yunze Zang, Miaogen Shen. Improving estimation of aboveground carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus stock in forest ecosystems by integrating radar and optical remote sensing [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(2): 1-.
[2]	Jiahui Chen, Nan Jia, Youcun Suo, Nan Hu, Guofu Zhao, Haiyang Gong, Zhiqiang Wang. Long-term yak-grazing alters plant fine-root C:N:P stoichiometry in a Tibetan alpine meadow [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[3]	Jingci Meng, Guodong Wang, Ming Wang, Meiling Zhao, Yusong Yuan, Nanlin Hu, Qi Chen, Tao Zhang, Bo Liu, Zhenshan Xue, and Ming Jiang. Abiotic and biotic factors jointly affect aboveground biomass in sedge wetlands of China [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[4]	Jiaoneng Yu, Fei Ren, Li Ma, Huakun Zhou, Xiaotao Huang, Yongsheng Yang, Songbo Qu, Yuxuan Cui, Ribu Shama, Yuxia Zhang, Xu-Ri, Almaz Borjigidai. Community dynamics of alpine meadows under fencing durations: based on diversity, niches, and interspecific associations [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[5]	Huiqi Zhang, Guangxuan Han, Wenli Jia, Wanxin Huang, Xiaoshuai Zhang, Xiaojie Wang, Mingliang Zhao, Baohua Xie, Feng Lu, Jianbin Song, Wei Zhang, Xiaojing Chu. Soil CO₂ not CH₄ flux determines soil carbon emission response to seasonal precipitation variation in a brackish wetland [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2026, 19(1): 1-.
[6]	Chunyue Yao, Jinchao Feng, Yeming Zhang, Zhenhua Dang, Linna Ma. Plant diversity dominates the regulation of ecosystem multifunctionality under grazing management in temperate grasslands [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(6): 1-40.
[7]	Guotai Zhang, Ga Zangjia, Ying Yang, Ci-ren Qu-zong, Yuan Zhang, Wei Mazhang, Cuo Se, Danzeng Quzhen, Jingting Mao, Chengwei Mu, Lan Wang, Shiping Wang, Zhiyong Yang, Tsechoe Dorji. Effects of warming and grazing on resource allocation strategies in alpine grasslands of the Tibetan Plateau: A Meta-analysis [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(4): 1-45.
[8]	Yixiao Tao, Xiaofeng Fu, Xia Xu, Qinghong Geng, Chonghua Xu, Chenghui Ju, Qian Li, Wenfang Liu, Xiaochou Chen. Responses of fine root dynamics to nitrogen application in global temperate forests and grasslands: inconsistencies between biomass and turnover [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-14.
[9]	Yanlong Li, Hao Wang, Yadong Wang1, Lin Wu, Ziyuan Ma, Dongjun Liu, Frank Yonghong Li. Adaptive grazing by three livestock species promotes plant species richness and density in the soil seed bank in a semi-arid grassland [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-12.
[10]	Jian-Guo Ma, Fu-Jiang Hou, Xiao-Bo Wang. Dissimilar soil nitrogen transformation features of dominant forage after intensive grazing on Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(3): 1-11.
[11]	Wangwang Lü, Jianping Sun, Bowen Li, Yang Zhou, Caiyun Luo, Zhenhua Zhang, Jingya Lü, Lanying Chen, Yonghui Wang, Jin-Sheng He, Tsechoe Dorji, Jinzhi Ding, Shiping Wang. Plant diversity modulates hierarchical responses of carbon cycle processes to warming and grazing in an alpine meadow [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(2): 1-16.
[12]	Ruiyu Fu, Qiaoyan Chen, Yangong Du, Licong Dai, Xiaowei Guo, Bo Fan, Qian Li, Zhongmin Hu. Soil hydrological properties in response to different grazing practices in the alpine meadows of the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(1): 1-11.
[13]	Min Zhang, Jun Wen, Xiaoli Wang, Cancan Zhao, Yuan Ma, Yushou Ma, Shixiong Li. Rest-grazing in spring affects the soil microbial community mainly by altering plant diversity [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2025, 18(1): 1-15.
[14]	Jingyuan Yang, Qi Xu, Yuxuan He, Meiguang Jiang, Minglu Ji, Linyu Qi, Huan Qi, Cancan Zhao, Yuan Miao, Shasha Liu, Yanfeng Sun. Effects of nitrogen and phosphorus addition on soil respiration in a soybean cropping system [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2024, 17(6): 1-13.
[15]	Shiwen Ding, Fons van der Plas, Jie Li, Bai Liu, Man Xu, Tongtong Xu, Xiaobin Pan, Qing Chang, Ying Chen, Yinong Li. Grazing effects on the relationship between plant functional diversity and soil carbon sequestration regulated by livestock species [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2024, 17(5): 1-12.