J Plant Ecol ›› 2019, Vol. 12 ›› Issue (3): 474-484.doi: 10.1093/jpe/rty040

• Research Articles • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Effects of monoculture-conditioned soils on common tallgrass prairie species productivity

Thomas P. McKenna1,*, Brian J. Darby2 and Kathryn A. Yurkonis2#br#   

  1. 1 Kansas Biological Survey, University of Kansas, 2101 Constant Ave., Takeru Higuchi Hall, Lawrence, KS 66047, USA
    2 Department of Biology, University of North Dakota, 10 Cornell Street Stop 9019, Grand Forks, ND 58202, USA
    *Correspondence address. Kansas Biological Survey, University of Kansas, 2101 Constant Ave., Takeru Higuchi Hall, Lawrence, KS 66047, USA. Tel: 785-864-1500; Fax: 785-864-1534; E-mail: tompatmck@gmail.com
  • Received:2017-12-18 Revised:2018-08-30 Accepted:2018-10-09 Online:2019-05-15 Published:2019-07-01



Within biodiversity–ecosystem function experiments, it is widely understood that yields of some species rapidly decline when planted in monoculture. This effect may arise due to decreased access to soil nutrients or an increase in detrimental soil pathogens within monoculture plantings. To determine whether or not soil conditioning affects tall grass prairie species biomass production, we conducted a field experiment to assess species growth in conspecifically and heterospecifically conditioned soils and a greenhouse experiment to elucidate how conspecific soil biota affected species growth.


To test for species-specific soil effects, seedlings of the legume Astragulus canadensis, the cool-season grass Elymus canadensis, the forb Helianthus maximiliani and the warm-season grass Panicum virgatum were grown in field plots that had either been conspecifically or heterospecifically conditioned over 2 years. Plant growth was recorded over a single growing season, and soils were assessed for differences in their nematode (mesofauna) communities. Seedlings of these species were additionally grown over a 6-week period in conspecifically conditioned soil that was either untreated, heated to 60°C, sterilized (autoclaved at 120°C) or heated to 60°C and reinoculated with conspecific soil biota. The two heating treatments were used to compare growth responses between a low- and high-temperature soil treatment. The reinoculation treatment was used to assess the effect of soil biota in light of any nutrient changes that may have occurred with soil heating.

Important Findings

ElymuscanadensisHmaximiliani and Pvirgatum growth was improved in field plots conditioned by the legume Acanadensis compared with their growth in conspecifically conditioned (home) soils. Despite variation (grass versus nongrass) in their soil nematode communities, there was no evidence to suggest that these three species were inhibited by conspecific or functionally conspecific soil conditioning in the field. Astragulus canadensis was the only species whose growth was reduced in conspecifically conditioned field soil. In the greenhouse, E. canadensis growth increased in all of the heat-treated soils, likely a response to a fertilization effect associated with soil heating. Panicum virgatum growth also increased among the heated soils. However, its growth decreased in heated soils where conspecific soil mesofauna were reintroduced, indicating that this grass may be inhibited by soil mesofauna. Finally, A. canadensis growth decreased in soils treated to fully remove soil biota and was not affected by reintroduction of soil mesofauna, suggesting that this species negatively responds to soil changes that occur with extreme heating. At least for the suite of tallgrass prairie species evaluated within this experiment, it appears that changes in soil chemistry and generalist soil biota, as opposed to increasing species-specific soil pathogens, more strongly contribute to temporal disparities in their performance.

Key words: Astragulus canadensis, diversity, Elymus canadensis, Helianthus maximiliani, monoculture, overyielding, Panicum
productivity, soil biota, soil conditioning

[1] Di Wang, Yi-Ran Zhang, Yu-Long Feng, Zhi Liu and Bo Qu. Changes in vegetation and soil properties following 6 years of enclosure in riparian corridors [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(2): 1-8.
[2] Verónica Loewe-Muñoz, Mónica Balzarini, Marta Ortega González. Pure and mixed plantations of Persian walnut (Juglans regia L.) for high quality timber production in Chile, South America [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(1): 12-19.
[3] Lu-Xi Chen, Su-Ting Xu, Wei-Hang Ding, Jun-Min Li and Peter Alpert. Genetic diversity and offspring fitness in the red and white fruit color morphs of the wild strawberry Fragaria pentaphylla [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(1): 36-41.
[4] Gianalberto Losapio, and Christian Schöb. Pollination interactions reveal direct costs and indirect benefits of plant–plant facilitation for ecosystem engineers [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2020, 13(1): 107-113.
[5] Yujing Yan and Zhiyao Tang. Protecting endemic seed plants on the Tibetan Plateau under future climate change: migration matters [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(6): 962-971.
[6] Betina Kellermann and André Eduardo Biscaia Lacerda. Arrested development? Investigating the role of bamboo in Araucaria Forest succession in Southern Brazil [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(6): 1034-1046.
[7] Zhiheng Wang, Yaoqi Li, Xiangyan Su, Shengli Tao, Xiao Feng, Qinggang Wang, Xiaoting Xu, Yunpeng Liu, Sean T. Michaletz, Nawal Shrestha, Markku Larjavaara, and Brian J. Enquist. Patterns and ecological determinants of woody plant height in eastern Eurasia and its relation to primary productivity [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(5): 791-803.
[8] Zhaoqi Wang, Jinfeng Chang, Shushi Peng, , Shilong Piao, Philippe Ciais and Richard Betts. Changes in productivity and carbon storage of grasslands in China under future global warming scenarios of 1.5°C and 2°C [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(5): 804-814.
[9] Yin Li, Helge Bruelheide, Thomas Scholten, Bernhard Schmid, Zhenkai Sun, Naili Zhang, Wensheng Bu, Xiaojuan Liu and Keping Ma. Early positive effects of tree species richness on soil organic carbon accumulation in a large-scale forest biodiversity experiment [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(5): 882-893.
[10] Mengesha Asefa, Calum Brown, Min Cao, Guocheng Zhang, Xiuqin Ci, Liqing Sha, Jie Li, Luxiang Lin and Jie Yang. Contrasting effects of space and environment on functional and phylogenetic dissimilarity in a tropical forest [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(2): 314-326.
[11] Andrea Oddershede, Cyrille Violle, Annette Baattrup-Pedersen, Jens-Christian Svenning and Christian Damgaard. Early dynamics in plant community trait responses to a novel, more extreme hydrological gradient [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(2): 327-335.
[12] Xiaohui Guo, Jana S. Petermann and Susanne Wurst. Interaction of a root-knot nematode (Meloidogyne hapla) and plant intraspecific diversity in clover-grass communities [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(1): 1-9.
[13] Roy R. Vera V., J. Hugo Cota-Sánchez and Jorge E. Grijalva Olmedo. Biodiversity, dynamics, and impact of chakras on the Ecuadorian Amazon [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(1): 34-44.
[14] Xiaoyang Song, Min Cao, Roger L. Kitching, Yong Tang, Zhenhua Sun, Akihiro Nakamura, Melinda J. Laidlaw and Jie Yang. Environmental and spatial contributions to seedling and adult tree assembly across tropical, subtropical and subalpine elevational gradients [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(1): 103-112.
[15] Rebekka B?gelein, Cecilia A. Pérez, Philipp Sch?fer and Frank M. Thomas. How competitive is the ‘pioneerclimax’ tree species Nothofagus alpina in pristine temperate forests#br# of Chile? [J]. J Plant Ecol, 2019, 12(1): 144-156.
Full text



[1] Yu Feng-lan;Wang Jing-ping;Li Jing-min and Shan Xue-qin. The Isolation and Identification of Sterols and Other Constituents from Seed Fat of Sapium sebiferum[J]. Chin Bull Bot, 1989, 6(02): 121 -123 .
[2] . [J]. Chin Bull Bot, 2000, 17(专辑): 8 -08 .
[3] LI Al-Fen;CHEN Min amd ZHOU Bai-Cheng. Advances and Problems in Studies of Photosynthetic Pigment-Protein Complexes of Brown Algae[J]. Chin Bull Bot, 1999, 16(04): 365 -371 .
[4] CHEN Xiao-Mei and GUO Shun-Xing. Research Advances in Plant Disease Resistive Material[J]. Chin Bull Bot, 1999, 16(06): 658 -664 .
[5] LI Ji-Quan JIN You-Ju SHEN Ying-Bai HONG Rong. The Effect of Environmental Factors on Emission of Volatile Organic Compounds from Plants[J]. Chin Bull Bot, 2001, 18(06): 649 -656 .
[6] . [J]. Chin Bull Bot, 2005, 22(增刊): 157 .
[7] LI Yan WANG Rong LI Guan GOU Ping. Purification and Properties of Alliinase from Fresh Garlic (Allium sativum)[J]. Chin Bull Bot, 2005, 22(05): 579 -583 .
[8] Jianxia Li, Chulan Zhang, Xiaofei Xia, Liangcheng Zhao. Cryo-sectioning Conditions and Histochemistry Comparison with Paraffin Sectioning[J]. Chin Bull Bot, 2013, 48(6): 643 -650 .
[9] JIANG Yang-Ming, CUI Wei-Hong, and DONG Qian-Lin. Comprehensive evaluation and analysis of tobacco planting environment based on space technology[J]. Chin J Plan Ecolo, 2012, 36(1): 47 -54 .
[10] Hu Cheng-biao, Zhu Hong-guang, Wei Yuan-lian. A Study on Microorganism and Biochemical Activity of Chinese-fir Plantation on Different Ecological Area in Guangxi[J]. Chin J Plan Ecolo, 1991, 15(4): 303 -311 .